Overview of the Kirkland vs. P790 Showdown

In a detailed comparison video on the H.I.T GOLF channel, hosted by Rick Shiels, the Costco Kirkland Signature irons are pitted against the premium TaylorMade P790 irons. This head-to-head test aims to determine if the budget-friendly Kirkland irons, priced significantly lower, can hold their own against a well-established name in golf equipment. The video meticulously examines various performance aspects of both sets, providing valuable insights for golfers looking for quality clubs at different price points.

Design and Build Comparison

Starting with the aesthetics and build, the video highlights the visual differences between the two iron sets. The TaylorMade P790 irons boast a sleek, premium design with a forged construction that appeals to serious golfers. In contrast, the Kirkland Signature irons, while visually appealing for their price, lack the same level of refinement in finish. At around the 3:45 mark, the host notes that the Kirkland irons still offer a surprisingly solid feel despite their lower cost, hinting at a competitive edge in terms of value.

Performance on the Range

Moving to on-course performance, the testing phase reveals critical data about distance, accuracy, and consistency. The TaylorMade P790 irons demonstrate superior distance and a tighter dispersion pattern, which is expected given their advanced technology and higher price point. However, around the 8:20 timestamp, it's pointed out that the Kirkland irons manage to deliver commendable distance and a forgiving nature, making them a viable option for mid-to-high handicap players who might not need the precision of premium clubs.

Feel and Feedback Analysis

Feel is another crucial factor in this comparison. The P790 irons provide exceptional feedback on well-struck shots, with a soft, responsive sensation that many golfers crave. The Kirkland irons, while not on the same level, still offer a decent feel for their category. At the 12:15 point in the video, the host emphasizes that the difference in feedback might not be as noticeable to less experienced golfers, suggesting that the Kirkland set could be more than adequate for casual or improving players.

Price-to-Performance Ratio

Perhaps the most striking aspect of this review is the discussion on value for money. The Kirkland Signature irons retail at a fraction of the cost of the TaylorMade P790s—often around £485 compared to over £1,000 for the P790 set. Near the 15:30 mark, the video underscores that while the P790s are undeniably superior in performance and craftsmanship, the Kirkland irons present an astonishing value proposition for budget-conscious golfers who still want playable, reliable equipment.

Target Audience for Each Set

The video also breaks down who each set of irons is best suited for. The TaylorMade P790s are ideal for low-handicap golfers or those willing to invest in top-tier equipment to maximize performance. On the other hand, the Kirkland irons cater to beginners or intermediate players looking for affordable gear without sacrificing too much quality. This segment, discussed around the 18:00 mark, helps viewers align their skill level and budget with the right choice of irons.